Progressive… ish

This week marked the opening of The Obama Presidential Center.  Rather than merely a facility to store and view the best and brightest moments of the eight-year Barack Obama presidency, it is very much something else.

We’ll start with eye catching!

Part museum, part community campus, part city park complete with a basketball court and barbecue grilling stations, along with vegetable gardens, walkways, a physical to-scale recreation of the Oval Office, as well as a destination, state-of-the-art, neighborhood gathering place housing numerous educational programs, classes and activities for people of all ages.

No, this is not a plug for the president or First Lady Michelle Obama, or the Center.

… though you can always get a picture with them

Even though the place seems quite impressive and cool to me.

And the former First Couple are, in my opinion, well, let’s just say sorely missed.

A wild understatement

Rather it is me urging everyone to take a look at two things:

The first is the ambition of what they are trying to create – something innately and historically American because it is a bit new and ingenious.

As was stated numerous times at its inaugural ceremonies on Friday, the building and grounds is not primarily a gauzy, nostalgic look-back at the Obama years. 

Annie Leibovitz's Portraits of President Obama and His Family | Vanity Fair
OK but can we look back at how adorable this family is/was???!

Instead it is an attempt to revitalize the First Lady’s hometown neighborhood on the south side of Chicago (Note: And his adopted one) by providing it with one of the largest, functional and certainly most expensive community centers in the country. 

A place that fosters education, teaches history (note: the successes as well as the failures of the O years), and encourages reflection. 

While at the same time giving the average local or far-away international tourist a fun place to hang out.

An out-of-the-box stab at something different.

That, in itself, serves as a more than apt metaphor and representation of what the Obamas and his presidency meant for the country at the time he was elected.

Click the picture to see more

But as impressive as all of this is, it was the theme and tenor of the former president’s remarks on opening day that really got to me, and got me thinking.

No, I will not be summarizing the speech or breaking it down.  You can watch it yourself here:   

Or better yet read the transcript of what he said here.

Rather it was his reminder to the crowd, and the worldwide audience no-doubt watching, that brings me to my second point.

Which is that despite the insanity currently happening, both in the country and within the now vomitous gold gilded Oval Office (Note: My words, he was far more polite), the 250 year history of the United States has always been a constant back and forth swing between freedom vs. repression, equality vs. racism  and the upper ruling class vs. the “poor.” (Note: I put “poor” in  quotes since 99% plus of us would be considered peons if we use present-day wealth disparities as the measure that determined who really ruled who).

Not to mention a perpetual fight for rights and non-discrimination by the many, and frankly countless, diverse minority groups comprising the essential tapestry fabric that is truly “America.”

What does it mean to be a country whose very founding was based on the tapestry principle (Note: Carole King excepted)?

Carole King: Tapestry Album Review | Pitchfork
OK but do listen to this album after you finish reading.

That despite all of our many faults we are still the only place in the world where you STILL AUTOMATICALLY AND LEGALLY become one of us, i.e. AMERICAN, because you live here.

As a child of immigrant grandparents, who grew up in a neighborhood of immigrants in the most immigrant populous and racially mixed U.S. city in the country during the most progressive decade in U.S. history (Note: NYC in the 1960s. And it didn’t seem so special at the time) I took all the mix and match cultural stuff sort of for granted.

But as an adult the reality of who we also are on the other side of big city inclusion has come crashingly into focus in too many unexpected and frankly, for me, unimaginable ways.

Reality GIFs | Tenor
It ain’t rainbows, my friend.

So when Pres. Obama got to the part of his speech were he spoke of the radical nature of our Founding Fathers for creating the FIRST country not ruled by kings and lords and the strong dominating the weak – aka “the many ruled by the few” it gave me pause. 

Especially when he pointed out that despite their writing a Declaration of Independence of “inalienable rights” every person in the country possessed, these were men who also left “slavery intact” while restricting voting to “white men who owned property.”

Constitution Day: Hamilton edition – The College of Arts & Sciences at  Texas A&M University
Checking my notes on Hamilton…

Therein laid one of many contradictions that is and always has been these United States.  A group of men with “the genius to provide us with a framework that allows each generation to make our union more (Note: Or less) perfect.”

As he recounted the pushing and pulling in each direction over more than two centuries (Note: See the above speech link) I was particularly taken with a quote from a Boston minister (Note: Usually attributed to Dr. Martin Luther King) during the Civil War era. 

This was a time when slaves would escape to the freedom of northern states only to be legally captured, shackled in chains and dragged, or sailed by ship, back down south.  And once again become mere property of their masters with nothing approaching inalienable rights of life, liberty and happiness.

I do not present to understand the moral universe,’ said Reverend Theodore Parker, one of the leading slave abolitionists from Boston at the time.  “..The arc is a long one… I cannot calculate the curve…by sight…. But from what I see, I am sure it bends towards justice.”

MANSFIELD: The Arc of the Moral Universe | CoolCleveland
Ok but how long?

Point being, that despite a lot of evidence to the contrary, namely the case of a young Boston man who had just been seized and hauled away by hundreds of armed officers back into slavery, Rev. Parker had lived and experienced enough in the country to know that in the long run this would never hold and that… eventually… justice would prevail.

I wanted to chalk this up to just another inspirational, glass half-filled Obama speech until that night, while cleaning out some of the physical files in my home office I came upon a news clipping from the N.Y. Post from 1964 my mother had saved.  It was about my third grade elementary school class and I hadn’t looked at in years. 

You might not be able to make out the wording in this copy, but here’s the first paragraph:

When the sun hits the windows in class 3-303 at P.S. 86 it is filtered through the blue cardboard tulips and orange paper daisies pasted to the panes.  In that mixture of gold, blue and orange sits Efrain, the lone Puerto Rican in the class.  Four other transfer students, all Negroes, are scattered through the room.  And there are 29 white students…

Truth be told, I had no idea we were one of the first forced busing, integrated schools in the state. 

Nor did I have any idea Efrain was Puerto Rican.  I just knew his skin had a slightly bronzed tint and the straight brownish blonde hair of the time that I had always wanted (Note: Yes, even then).

But I do remember him, as the last paragraph of the article states, at the blackboard. 

And the adjacent window covered in blue construction paper and orange daisies  

Where he quickly added up a series of numbers much faster than any of the rest of us could.

As for the four “Negro” kids, it never occurred to me that this was unusual.  I didn’t really think about it.  And strange as it might seem to you now, few, if any, of the rest of us did.

That WAS America in that moment in time. 

For me.

And my friends.

And I suspect it will be again.

Or at least, can be.

Bruce Springsteen – “Land of Hope and Dreams”

American Exceptionalism

If you want to see any real life examples of the above, look no further than the actions of one gold medal-winning American ice skater at this year’s winter Olympics. 

Because you won’t find them in the turdly pronouncements from the occupant-in-chief of our freshly minted gold gilded White House.

A rare moment of checks and balances

Twenty-one year old Ilia Malinin, dubbed the skating world’s Quad God, aka the first athlete on Earth to rotate four and a half times in the air on ice skates dozens and dozens of times competitively, helped lead the Americans to an overall team gold medal in ice skating.

That was because when asked at the last minute he agreed to skate his long-form solo program as a key component in the American team event, and save them from an anticipated loss, rather than rest up and wait for his solo competition a handful of days later where he could simply have employed it all for his own glory.

Ilia Malinin's stunning free skate secures US figure skating team gold at  Milan Cortina Olympics - Anchorage Daily News
USA Team Golden Boy

The result was young Mr. Malinin helped win Gold for the team but was unable to duplicate that same stellar performance in his Olympic solo debut, where he stumbled badly and landed in eight place.

Yet unlike what we hear daily from the Oval Office of Outrage there were no excuses, no blame game (Note: Unless blaming himself counts) and no accusation of a rigged voting system that gave an unfair advantage to his opponents.

In fact, after hearing his disappointing score the first thing the much favored 21-year-old did was to march directly over to his competitor and now new gold medal winner, Mikhail Shaidorov of Kazakhstan, and embrace him in a long hug.

Where he could be heard telling him: You deserve it.

Wait What GIFs | Tenor
Integrity? What?!

It’s been quite a long time since we’ve heard any sort of admission of loss, much less an admission of blame, from the upper echelons of the American political or business elite.

Somehow it’s become okay for a small group of uber billionaires, led by the tech bro class of MAGA friendly contributors like Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg, Jeff Bezos and Larry Ellison, to hold more wealth than the bottom 50% of American households – aka over 170 million people.

Sickening GIFs | Tenor
Barf

Not to begrudge anyone the fruits of their labor (Note: Fruits that are enabled through the perks of living in a democracy where they are free to think of the rest of us as mere nuisance shareholders) but that means they control more than 31% of the wealth in the entire U.S, a wealth that has increased 21% (Note: AKA $8.1 billion) in the year since the Golden King of MAGA took office.

Speaking of which, when the massive tariffs he was doling out randomly, and at his whimsy, to countries all over the world, were deemed constitutionally illegal this week in a rare rebuke to him from the far right leaning majority in the U.S. Supreme Court, there were no hugs.

Nor was there any respect from him for the rules, decorum and otherwise, or the judges.

Dramatic Baby Reactions Make You LOL 2026 🤣 Try Not To Laugh Challenge!
Perfect representation of POTUS reaction

Instead, there were proclamations that instead of tariffing specific countries he would try and stretch his presidential powers and go around the ruling by issuing a blanket 15% world tariff to everyone country in the world (Note: The latter edict can last only 150 days, unless extended by Congress).

But most notably there were also the insults and invectives from the soon-to-be 80-year-old squatter in our White House Executive Residence, which he has become known for. 

Calling the judges who voted against his wishes “a disgrace to their families” and “an embarrassment to the nation.”  Accusing them of being “very unpatriotic and disloyal to our constitution.”

This x 1000

And this was a continuance of an invective of insults he tweeted in the months running up to the decision. Speaking in November of those who opposed his tariff policies, which have cost the average American household $1000-$1300 on imported goods last year, he wrote on his personal platform, Truth Social:

Evil, American hating Forces are fighting us at the United States Supreme Court…. Pray to God that our Nine Justices will show great wisdom, and do the right thing for America!

Well, I suppose you could say that is an exceptional statement because when you use exceptional as an adjective it means unusual or not typical.  Also, if you consider the entirety of American presidents, that statement is both not typical AND unusual.

Bernie Sanders . This Is Not Normal GIF | GIFDB.com
Yes Bernie, we know

But American exceptionalism, thought to be first coined by the French historian Alexis de Tocqueville in relation to the U.S, was originally centered around the idea that this country was unique because it was not centered on a ruling class or elite but rather aspired to rights of freedom and liberty for all laid out in its founding documents, the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution.

Yet as time and centuries evolved the term began to evolve into something it was never intended to mean.  Something that does not at all apply to what made our country exceptional, nor what others deemed exceptional about it to begin with.

Typical GIFs | Tenor
nuff said

From the dreadful 1980s until now, the phrase was somehow co-opted, nee appropriated, by American right wing politicians and leading members of the modern Republican Party as a way to own patriotism and assert their position as THE keepers of MORALITY in the U.S. 

America is THE most freedom-loving, THE least corrupt and THE great example of the moral high ground the world has ever seen.  Especially those Americans who are church-going, conservative, and married with children.

Case closed.  And no arguments.  Especially these days.

Fingers In Ears GIFs | Tenor
la la la la la la

That was the mantra as I all too clearly heard it as far back as the Reagan era and its only become more cemented in stone as the decades have worn on.

In fact, former Republican Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich, a guy who cheated on his first and second wives, the latter when she was suffering from a brain tumor, even wrote a book in  2012 called, A Nation Like No Other: Why American Exceptionalism Matters, where among other things he argues that one of the reasons we’re so great is our rights are granted by God, not the government.

This would, of course, be news to the Founding Fathers, who purposely left direct references to God out of the U.S. Constitution in order to enshrine the country as one with a secular, non-theocratic government.

Hamilton Musical GIFs - Find & Share on GIPHY
You know.. these guys

And news to France, which gifted the Statue of Liberty to the country with the greatest melting pot of immigration in the world – the United States – in 1884.

And to poet Emma Lazarus, who was asked at a fundraising event that year to donate a poem that could be engraved on its base.  At the time she had been working to aid refugees in New York who had fled antisemitic pogroms in Eastern Europe (Note: My ancestors).  So she came up with the sonnet, The New Colossus, and the now famous lines that have welcomed all immigrants who passed through the New York Harbor by boat, or symbolically by other means, for the last 150 years.

Give me your tired, your poor, Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, The wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me, I lift my lamp beside the golden door!

One shudders at the misplaced irony of those words in our current calendar year.

And in the previous one.

It can always get worse

Though not so coincidentally, Ilia Malinin’s parents are both immigrants  Yup. Skating couple Tatiana Malinina and Roman Skorniakov, from Uzbekistan and Russia, respectively.  They were world class competitors who immigrated to the U.S. for a better life and became coaches at an elite ice skating club in Virginia.

It is there that Ilia, a first generation American was born, educated and learned not only his sport but sportsmanship that made him a world class leader of team America.  Not only in the moments he won but for the way he acted when not EVERYTHING went his way.

(will not make Heated Rivalry joke even though I want to)

That was not only exceptional but the true definition of American exceptionalism.

Or it should be.

Watch ILIA MALININ cinch gold here